Instability, conflict and disaster: an educational perspective

Dr Wonyong Park EDUC3028 Week 8

Session outline

  1. 1Education for, about and in crises
  2. 2Learning from 3/11: evacuation, memory and displacement
  3. 3Global frameworks and the unequal impacts of disruption
  4. 4Education under war: Gaza, Ukraine and teaching the conflict
Education fordisasters Education aboutdisasters Education indisasters

Sustainable peacebuilding in education: the 4Rs analytical framework

Redistribution
  • Equitable access to education and fair distribution of resources
  • Whether reforms and policies deliver fair outcomes, such as qualifications and jobs
Recognition
  • Language of instruction and cultural diversity in the curriculum
  • Place of religious and cultural identity, and civic education in state-building
Reconciliation
  • Addressing past and present injustices, including how the past is taught
  • Whether education builds social cohesion and trust between groups and with institutions
Representation
  • Participation of teachers, parents and students in policy and school governance
  • Political control of education, and whether it supports fundamental freedoms

Novelli, Lopes Cardozo & Smith, 2017

Tectonic plates around Japan
World map of tectonic plates with arrows marking Japan and the North Atlantic

The Great East Japan Earthquake 2011

Inset map of Japan with the Tōhoku region outlined
Map of Iwate, Miyagi and Fukushima with Kamaishi, Ishinomaki, Minamisōma and Fukushima Daiichi marked

Japan is an island country in East Asia. Honshū is its largest island, and Tōhoku is its north-eastern region.

Miyagi & Iwate
School tsunami cases
Fukushima
Nuclear accident and life after it

A prefecture is an administrative region, roughly comparable to a county.

Map: Natural Earth/Basemap coastlines; approximate city locators.

One event set off three connected disasters

At 2:46 pm on March 11, 2011, a magnitude 9.0 earthquake struck offshore. Its consequences unfolded across Japan’s north-eastern Pacific coast.

1Earthquake

Ground shaking

Strong shaking damaged buildings, roads and power systems. Schools stopped lessons and began emergency procedures.

2Tsunami

Seawater surges inland

An undersea earthquake displaced water, sending destructive waves onto the coast and up rivers. Many communities were devastated.

3Nuclear accident

Reactor cooling fails

At Fukushima Daiichi, tsunami flooding disabled cooling equipment. Reactor damage and explosions released radioactive materials.

Schools had to act immediately; later, society had to learn how to understand and live with the disaster.

Japan Meteorological Agency (2011); Morimoto (2023), introduction; TEPCO, accident overview.

Okawa: the children waited while the tsunami approached

Okawa was a small primary school about 4 km inland beside the Kitakami River. Its staff knew they needed to keep pupils safe, but the tsunami danger and the next evacuation step were disputed.

  1. 2:46 pmThe earthquake struck; teachers assembled the pupils in the school playground.
  2. AfterwardsStaff debated where to go. The emergency manual did not name a specific safe location.
  3. Before the waveSome pupils tried or urged others to climb the nearby hill; the group remained below.
  4. Too lateThe group moved towards a bridge shortly before the river-borne tsunami overtook them.
Okawa school building preserved after the tsunami

Okawa school building preserved after the tsunami

74 pupils + 10 teachers died
A written emergency plan cannot substitute for clear decisions and routes under uncertainty.

Parry (2017), “The Last Hour of the Old World”; Gerster & Shibayama (2025), pp. 12–13.

Kadonowaki: rehearsed evacuation helped children survive

Kadonowaki Elementary School building damaged by tsunami and fire

Kadonowaki Elementary · tsunami and fire damaged the building

All 227 pupils and staff present escaped.

Another primary school in the same city, Ishinomaki, faced not just the earthquake and tsunami but also fires spreading from nearby buildings.

1
Regular drills

Pupils and staff were familiar with what to do in an emergency.

2
Older helping younger

A well-established school practice helped pupils move safely.

3
Evacuation beyond the school

The pupils’ actions encouraged neighbours to follow them.

Seven pupils who were elsewhere and some nearby residents nevertheless died; this was not a loss-free event.

Gerster & Shibayama (2025), pp. 10–11.

Kamaishi: survivors rejected the word “miracle”

At Kamaishi Higashi Middle School in Iwate, older pupils helped younger children from a neighbouring primary school escape. They did not stop at the first planned refuge: the group moved further uphill.

1LEAVE

Pupils began evacuating after the earthquake.

2HELP

Older pupils took the hands of younger children.

3GO HIGHER

They continued uphill rather than stopping at the first site.

“Most of all, it was thanks to our education that we were able to make these decisions.”
A former pupil interviewed by Gerster & Shibayama · around 600 people reached the hill

Gerster & Shibayama (2025), pp. 16–17.

When a damaged school becomes a memorial

After 3/11, some ruins were preserved instead of demolished. By 2025, seven former school buildings were officially turned into disaster memorial museums.

Okawa school ruins

Okawa: a place of loss

Kadonowaki museum interior with damaged desks

Kadonowaki: a pupil’s view

Balloons released at Arahama school

Arahama: ongoing commemoration

Why schools?

Many were strong public buildings that remained standing. They were also shared places filled with memories of lessons, friendships, festivals and everyday life.

A school can become evidence of a disaster, a place to mourn, and a place to teach future visitors.

Gerster & Shibayama (2025), pp. 1–5, 15–16, 19–23.

Schools as disaster memorials

Video: Lessons from Japan’s tsunami (UNDRR)

Remembering Okawa is still contested

The ruins of Okawa were preserved after public debate, including an appeal from a surviving pupil. But a memorial is not neutral: different groups ask it to do different things.

Bereaved families

Remember the children, explain failures and seek accountability.

Other local residents

Protect memories of a living community and avoid repeated trauma.

Public visitors and officials

Learn preparedness lessons; manage costs, access and exhibitions.

Mural of children at the preserved Okawa school site

Mural at the preserved Okawa school site

As of 2025, the official exhibition offered limited details about the failed evacuation; much was conveyed by bereaved guides (kataribe).
QuestionWho has the authority to decide what a disaster memorial teaches?

Gerster & Shibayama (2025), pp. 12–13, 19, 22.

A nuclear disaster changed questions about daily life

Empty street in Tomioka, Fukushima, seen from inside a car

Tomioka, Fukushima · empty streets photographed by Polleri

The tsunami damaged Fukushima Daiichi, a nuclear power station. Failures of reactor cooling systems caused severe accidents and releases of radioactive substances.

People had to decide whether to leave or return, whether food was safe, and what future risks meant for their families. These questions continued long after the earthquake.

Radiation is invisible. Instruments can measure exposure and dose rates, but a number needs context to guide decisions.
Public education now had to communicate an invisible hazard and its uncertainties, not only evacuation routes.

Morimoto (2023), introduction and chs. 1, 5; Polleri (2021), pp. 94–100.

How official exhibitions explained radiation

Anthropologist Maxime Polleri studied educational centres and exhibitions built or used after Fukushima. He calls their repeated messages “radioactive performances”.

Familiar

Radiation is also natural

Displays compared Fukushima measurements with everyday background radiation, such as exposure during flights or in food.

Playful

Make a frightening topic fun

Cartoon characters, interactive games and simple language aimed to make the subject less intimidating.

Impressive

Show technology’s benefits

Exhibitions celebrated detectors, medical radiation and scientific instruments as useful innovations.

Educational benefit

Clearer, more approachable scientific ideas.

Criticism

Selective emphasis could make risks and disputes less visible.

Polleri (2021), pp. 95–96, 101–15.

A children’s decontamination game at a Fukushima exhibition

Educational decontamination model: a miniature house and garden covered in red balls

The educational decontamination model

What children did

They used a toy shovel to remove red balls representing radioactive contaminants from a miniature house and garden, placing the balls into small waste bags.

What is taught well? What might be missing?
Interpretation

The game can make cleanup appear straightforward while obscuring workers’ difficulties, residual contamination and contested recovery.

Polleri (2021), pp. 109–10; Figure 3, p. 110.

Figure 2. Monitoring devices available for public use at DIP

Evacuation disrupted students’ lives

Almost 8% of Fukushima’s schoolchildren evacuated outside the prefecture.

Leaving the coastal towns meant rebuilding everyday life while coping with the disaster’s losses.

Displacement

Unstable living arrangements

Families moved between evacuation centres, temporary housing and new towns. Students had to adjust while grieving lost homes, communities and, in some cases, loved ones.

Belonging

Loss of familiar relationships

Evacuation separated children from their social networks. In unfamiliar schools, some experienced isolation and struggled to settle in or make new connections.

Schooling

Pressure to resume school

Some pupils travelled to relocated “satellite schools”, leaving home as early as 6 a.m. Normal timetables and exam demands resumed despite displacement and distress.

Reopening schools restored routines, but left little time to discuss loss, fear and disrupted lives.

Miyazawa (2022), ch. 5, pp. 83–88.

New schools could bring new difficulties

Evacuation did not end the disaster’s effects. Students also faced stigma and difficulties sharing their experiences.

Stigma

Bullying and exclusion

Peers called evacuees “radiation” or “virus” and told them to stay away. These insults treated Fukushima children as a source of contamination.

Identity

Hiding where they came from

A teacher reported that some evacuated children concealed their Fukushima origins for fear of bullying. Seeking safety could also mean losing a sense of belonging.

Schools needed to address bullying and create time and space for students to share experiences at their own pace.
The Independent: Japanese school children who survived Fukushima meltdown are being subjected to ‘nuclear bullying’

Miyazawa (2022), ch. 5, pp. 95–97; ch. 6, pp. 106–107.

Activity 1

Think back to an emergency drill or safety routine from your own school days.

Did it prepare you to make decisions, or only to follow instructions?

Kadonowaki and Kamaishi show what works. What would it take for a school today to prepare pupils that well?

UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction

Words Into Action: A Guide for Implementing the Hyogo Framework
Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015–2030 cover
Excerpt: To promote the incorporation of disaster risk knowledge, including disaster prevention, mitigation, preparedness, response, recovery and rehabilitation, in formal and non-formal education, as well as in civic education at all levels, as well as in professional education and training
UNDRR: UN Office for Disaster Risk Reduction

The Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction

Video: What is the Sendai Framework? (UNDRR)
COPE: Blizzards comic cover
COPE comic page: what should we do before a blizzard?

Unequal impacts of disasters

Figure 2.7: Estimated mean learning loss by spring term, in scaled score points, in reading (primary and secondary schools) by pupil and area-level disadvantage

*FSM: Free School Meal
*IDACI: Income Deprivation Affecting Children Index

Renaissance Learning & Education Policy Institute (2021). Understanding Progress in the 2020/21 Academic Year

Lockdown widened the education gap in deprived areas

Video: Children in deprived areas face widening education gap due to lockdown (BBC News)

Education under war: Gaza, Ukraine and teaching the conflict

  • Ukraine
    Schools open under air-raid alerts; pupils displaced abroad
  • Gaza
    Schooling moved into tents and temporary spaces
  • Israel
    Remembrance and dialogue after 7 October
RUSSIABELARUSPOLANDROMANIATÜRKIYEEGYPTSYRIAJORDANBlack SeaMediterranean Sea Ukraine Gaza Israel
Borders follow international recognition (approximate). Base map: Natural Earth.

Gaza: schooling has moved into tents and temporary spaces

Since October 2023, almost no child in Gaza has had a formal school day. UNICEF estimates ~700,000 children aged 4–17 have missed almost three years of in-person schooling.

98%

of school buildings damaged (Apr 2026)

564,000

children in 695 temporary learning spaces

200,000

children with no structured learning

  • 68% of children aged 5–11 had three months or less of learning since Oct 2023.
  • Barriers: cost, distance, damaged schools and safety.
  • Limited offer: a temporary-space place often means a short day and few subjects.
  • Recovery: catch-up in Arabic and maths, combined with play and emotional support.
A man carries a child past a damaged school building in Gaza where displaced families are sheltering

A damaged school in Gaza sheltering displaced families

Sources: UNICEF State of Palestine education update (2026); OCHA humanitarian situation reports, 15 Oct & 5 Nov 2026; UNICEF Gaza child-focused assessment; UNICEF catch-up programmes.

Ukraine: schools stay open, but alerts break up the day

4.2m

children returned to learning in Sept 2026

90%

of secondary schools teach in person or blended

34 hrs

under alert in school hours this term – over 13% of learning time

School days with air-raid alerts (%)
37.4% 65.9% Sep–Oct 2025 Sep–Oct 2026
  • Kyiv: school-time alarms rose from 12 (Sept 2025) to 71 (Sept 2026).
  • Dnipropetrovsk, Kirovohrad, Kharkiv: 60+ hours of alarms – about a quarter of learning time.

Shelters as classrooms

UNICEF helped convert 22 underground shelters near the front line into schools.

Attacks on education

~2,000 UN-verified attacks since 2022; 4,200+ institutions damaged.

Power cuts

Strikes on energy cut electricity, heating and internet for remote learners.

Sources: Ukraine Ministry of Education and Science; UNICEF press releases on air-raid alerts (3 Nov 2026) and the fifth school year under attack.

Ukrainian refugee children at school in another country

Video: What's it like for Ukrainian refugees at school in another country? (BBC Newsround)

Higher education: campuses, labs and staff lost

Gaza: 36 of 38 campuses destroyed or damaged

22 destroyed 14 damaged 2 other
195 / 206

buildings destroyed or severely damaged

1,112

staff killed, detained or injured (22%)

US$373m

assessed damage across 21 institutions

A research institute building in Israel with its facade destroyed by a missile strike

Israel: a research institute damaged by an Iranian missile strike (CNBC-TV18)

Gaza: teaching online and in tents

UNESCO supports temporary learning spaces for 10,000 students and a virtual campus.

Ukraine: among the costliest damage

Damage to universities and labs interrupts practical training and research.

Sources: UNESCO assessment of damage to higher education institutions in Gaza (Nov 2025); Ukraine's Fifth Rapid Damage and Needs Assessment (RDNA5, 2026).

The Lucens Guidelines: keeping schools and universities out of military use

Cover: Draft Lucens Guidelines for Protecting Schools and Universities from Military Use during Armed Conflict, GCPEA

Draft text, Global Coalition to Protect Education from Attack (GCPEA), 2014

Armed forces have turned schools into bases, barracks, firing positions and armouries. This can make a school a military objective, and leads to drop-out and lower attainment – girls are often most affected.

  1. 1

    Functioning schools: never used for the military effort, even outside class hours or in holidays.

  2. 2

    Abandoned schools: used only if no feasible alternative, for the minimum time, then cleared and repaired.

  3. 3

    No destruction: schools are civilian objects; never destroy them to deny their future use.

  4. 4

    Before an attack: consider alternatives, warn in advance and weigh the special care owed to children.

  5. 5

    Security: troops guard schools only when risk is high and no civilian option exists – ideally outside the grounds.

  6. 6

    Into doctrine: build the Guidelines into military manuals, rules of engagement and orders.

GCPEA (2014). Draft Lucens Guidelines for Protecting Schools and Universities from Military Use during Armed Conflict (text of 22 October 2014), Preface and Guidelines 1–6.

How the war is taught in Ukraine and Israel

Ukraine writes the war into its curriculum and into practical defence training. In Israel, schools centre on remembrance, emotional support and dialogue.

Ukraine

  • History: a new unit on the war since 2014.
  • Defence of Ukraine (grades 10–11): information warfare, first aid, civilian protection.
In the classroom
  • One full day a month at a training hub, practising tactical first aid with tourniquets and mannequins.
  • Grade 11 pupils learn drone control on FPV simulators.

Israel

  • Ministry guidance links remembrance of 7 October with age-appropriate talk about hostages and bereavement.
  • Hand in Hand bilingual Jewish–Arab schools offer facilitated dialogue.
In the classroom
  • Anniversary lessons built on personal memories, stories of bravery, guided conversation and recovery, with group talks led by school psychologists.
  • Hand in Hand’s high school runs dialogue classes where students may speak or stay silent.

Sources: Ukraine MoES; Ukrainska Pravda (2024, 2025); Kyiv Independent; Israeli Ministry of Education via Jerusalem Post; The World (2024); Ynetnews; Hand in Hand.

Beyond the war zones: contested texts and classroom voice

What educators and policymakers debate

Whose history appears in the curriculum?

  • European Commission (2025): the Palestinian Authority committed to revising textbooks against UNESCO standards.
  • Independent UNRWA review (2024) examined concerns about bias, antisemitic content and incitement, alongside existing safeguards.
  • But textbook oversight says little about how teachers use materials, especially in emergency classrooms.

When and how should teachers open discussion?

  • 2026 case study, mixed Jewish–Palestinian high school in Israel: avoiding conflict also silenced Palestinian students' collective identity.
  • DfE guidance (England) uses the conflict to show how to present competing views fairly while challenging inaccurate claims.
  • Educate Against Hate (England) hosts materials on Israel and Palestine: online fact-checking, sensitive terminology, anti-Jewish and anti-Muslim bullying.
Both debates ask who decides what students learn about a war – questions of recognition and representation.

Sources: European Parliament answer E-001465/2025; UNRWA independent review; Teaching and Teacher Education (2026); DfE; Educate Against Hate.

Activity 2

When we educate about these armed conflicts, what are the key considerations for each of the 4Rs?

Redistribution
Recognition
Representation
Reconciliation

Key takeaways

Five ways to think about disaster & education

  1. 1

    Crises amplify inequality: disadvantaged and frontline pupils lose the most.

  2. 2

    Preparation is practised, not written: rehearsed drills saved lives at Kadonowaki and Kamaishi, while a written plan failed at Okawa.

  3. 3

    Disruption outlasts closure: displacement, stigma and pressure to “return to normal” affect pupils for years.

  4. 4

    Education is casualty and actor: schools are damaged and attacked, yet they also rebuild routines and support recovery.

  5. 5

    Memory is political: memorials, exhibitions and curricula choose what a crisis teaches, so ask who decides.

→ / Space / click: next · ← back · F full screen · O overview · move the mouse for controls