The teaching profession under pressure

Global challenges and the case of England

Dr Wonyong Park EDUC1033 Week 9 · Lecture
Dobrislava, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Session outline

  1. 1What would count as a crisis in teacher supply?
  2. 2International evidence on teachers' work
  3. 3England: recruitment, retention, workload and pay
  4. 4Policy responses and a summary of the evidence
Activity 1In pairs3 minutesOpen Mentimeter ↗
BBC News: Emergency measures needed to stop teachers quitting, say Lib Dems. 31 August 2026. The Guardian: Number of teachers in England’s state schools drops for second year in row.

What would count as a crisis in teacher supply?

"Crisis" suggests a serious problem that existing arrangements are failing to manage. In discussions of teaching, the word can refer to several connected problems.

Recruitment
Too few people apply to train, start training or enter teaching posts.
Retention
Too many teachers leave a school, the state-funded sector or the occupation.
Matching
Teachers are scarce in particular subjects or places, such as physics or some regions.
Working conditions
Teachers in post find the work difficult to sustain.
An education system can improve on one of these measures while continuing to struggle on another.

Teacher supply works like a pipeline

ApplyAccept offerStart trainingGain QTSEnter a post Stay anddevelop withdrawdeclineleave coursedo not qualifydo not enterleave later

Long & Bridges (2026), section 2; Worth & Scott (2026), pp. 10–17; report section 1.

International evidence on teachers' work

UNESCO's estimate of global teacher need, and the OECD's TALIS 2024 survey of teachers' working lives.

A classroom in Japan · Darklanlan, Wikimedia Commons, CC0

UNESCO estimates that 44 million more teachers are needed by 2030

The estimate covers the additional primary and secondary teachers needed to achieve universal education at these levels. Around 15 million of them are in sub-Saharan Africa.

Sub-Saharan Africa · ~15m
Rest of the world · ~29m

Additional teachers needed by 2030, total 44 million

Expansion

More children need places in school, or the pupil population is growing. This need exists even if every teacher stays.

Replacement

Teachers retire, change occupation or leave. A system with falling pupil numbers can still face shortages if departures are high.

Distribution

International recruitment moves teachers between systems, with effects in both the sending and receiving countries.

UNESCO & International Task Force on Teachers for Education 2030 (2024), Global report on teachers.

The OECD links job demands and resources to teachers' outcomes

Personal factorsdemographics, experience, career pathways
Policies and regulations

Job demands

  • Workload (volume and variety of tasks)
  • Work pressure (accountability and performance evaluation)
  • Student behaviour and discipline
  • Diverse learning needs within a group
  • Uncertainty and change

Job resources

  • Pre- and in-service learning opportunities
  • Teacher leadership and autonomy
  • Support from school leaders, colleagues and parents
  • Terms of employment
  • Social status

Personal resources

  • Self-efficacy
  • Growth mindset
  • Motivation

Professional outcomes

Teaching outcomesFulfilment of lesson aims
WellbeingStress, work-life balance, mental and physical health
Job satisfactionWith the profession, workplace and overall
Career intentionsFurther years expected in teaching
Contextual factorsschool and classroom characteristics

OECD (2025), Results from TALIS 2024, Figure 1, p. 24, after Bakker & Demerouti (2017) and Granziera et al. (2020). © OECD, CC BY 4.0.

TALIS 2024: what the survey covers

The OECD's Teaching and Learning International Survey asks teachers and school leaders about their work. Its main comparisons are of lower secondary teachers. Results were published in 2025.

Self-report
Teachers describe their own experiences of support, workload and stress.
OECD average
The average across participating OECD education systems.
England
England took part in TALIS 2018 but not in TALIS 2024. Evidence on England in this session comes from DfE statistics, the Working Lives survey and NFER.

OECD (2025), Reader's Guide; OECD TALIS participation lists.

Reported working hours differ widely between systems

OECD Figure 3.2: change in teachers' total working hours 2018 to 2024 by system England 2024 · 50.3 h* England 2018 · 49.3 h 1 2

Weekly hours reported by full-time lower secondary teachers. Each comet runs from 2018 (tail) to 2024 (head).

1

Japan reports around 55 hours a week, after a significant fall since 2018.

2

The OECD average is about 41 hours a week.

Chart: OECD (2025), Fig. 3.2, p. 108 (CC BY 4.0). England: Jerrim & Sims (2019), Table 3.1.1; IFF/UCL (2025), Working lives wave 3, §3.
2018: full-time lower secondary. 2024*: full-time state secondary. Different surveys and populations; indicative comparison.

Most teachers report job satisfaction, and some report high stress

~9 in 10

lower secondary teachers are satisfied with their job (OECD average)

19%

experience stress at work "a lot"

A teacher can value working with pupils and the purpose of teaching while finding workload, pay, leadership or accountability difficult.

TALIS asks about several aspects of wellbeing: stress, time for personal life, and effects on mental and physical health.

Interviews with teachers in England who had left or were considering leaving also describe valued relationships with pupils alongside pressures of the job.

OECD (2025), pp. 73–76; IFF Research & UCL IOE (2026).

England: recruitment, retention, workload and pay

DfE statistics, NFER's annual labour market report, and the Working Lives of Teachers and Leaders survey.

Albany Senior School, Enfield, 1943 · Ministry of Information, public domain

How England's system is organised

England, not the UK

Education is devolved. England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland differ on qualifications, training routes and early career support.

State-funded schools include maintained schools and academies.

QTS and the PGCE

Qualified teacher status is a professional status for meeting the Teachers' Standards. A PGCE is an academic award.

An undergraduate Education degree does not automatically award QTS.

Headcount and FTE

Headcount counts people; FTE counts full-time posts. A teacher moving to part-time work reduces FTE.

Primary pupil numbers are falling, while secondary and special schools follow different patterns.

Long & Bridges (2026); DfE, Get Into Teaching; Worth & Scott (2026), pp. 4, 8–10.

Routes into teaching in England

Route and shareIn brief
Undergraduate ITT16.6%
Degree with preparation for QTS
Teacher degree apprenticeship0.6%
Employed degree-level training
Postgraduate, fee-funded70.2%
For graduates; QTS, often a PGCE
Postgraduate, salaried12.6%
Training in a salaried school post
Assessment-onlyExperienced teachers without QTS
Overseas-trainedRecognition, subject to criteria

Partnership

Schools provide practice and mentoring. Universities contribute research, subject knowledge, educational study and academic awards. Many routes involve both.

After QTS

Early career teachers (ECTs) receive a two-year induction. The Early Career Teacher Entitlement, introduced from September 2025, links to the ITT and Early Career Framework.

Long & Bridges (2026), §§2.1, 3.2; DfE, Initial Teacher Training Census 2025/26 (provisional); shares calculated from entrant counts.

A critical perspective on teacher education

In Teacher Education in Crisis, Ellis and Childs (2024) argue that reforms in England intensified central control over training providers and constrained the contribution of universities.

Their account draws on the experiences of teacher educators.

It connects teacher supply to a wider question: how practical competence, knowledge of subjects and pupils, and professional judgement fit together in teacher preparation, and who decides.

Historical photograph of a teacher at a blackboardFortepan 3612, Wikimedia Commons, public domain

Ellis & Childs (2024), "Introducing the crisis", in V. Ellis (Ed.), Teacher Education in Crisis, pp. 1–26.

Recruitment to postgraduate training rose in 2025/26

NFER chart: postgraduate ITT recruitment vs target 2019/20 to 2025/26, primary 128%, secondary 89% 1 2

Postgraduate initial teacher training (ITT) recruitment as a percentage of the DfE target.

1

Secondary recruitment fell to under half of target in 2023/24.

2

In 2025/26, primary reached 128% of target and secondary 89%. NFER links the improvement partly to weaker job opportunities for graduates elsewhere.

Worth & Scott (2026), NFER, p. 10, using DfE ITT Census data.

Both the number of recruits and the target changed

Secondary postgraduate ITT, rounded figures

2024/25

Target24,000
Recruits61% of target15,000

2025/26

Target19,000
Recruits89% of target17,000

Recruits rose by about 2,000. The target fell by about 5,000. Both changes raised the percentage of target met.

A target is an estimate of future need, based on pupil numbers, retention, returners and other sources of teachers.

Part of the rise in the percentage came from a lower target.

Worth & Scott (2026), p. 10; report section 11.

Recruitment against target varies widely by subject

2025/26 secondary postgraduate ITT recruitment vs target by subject 1 2

Secondary postgraduate ITT recruitment by subject, 2025/26, as a percentage of each subject's target.

1

Nine of eighteen subjects were below target, including business studies (30%), physics (78%) and computing (81%).

2

Physical education recruited twice its target (204%). Extra trainees in one subject cannot fill vacancies in another.

NFER analysis of DfE ITT Census 2025/26; Worth & Scott (2026), p. 11.

Students' accounts of teacher shortages

Video: Students say they are 'falling behind' due to chronic teacher shortages (Sky News)

NFER's forecast for 2026/27 shows changes by subject

ITT recruitment vs target: 2025/26 actual vs 2026/27 forecast by subject 1 2

Purple: 2025/26 recruitment. Blue: NFER forecast for 2026/27, based on applications to February 2026.

1

Computing (~99%) and physics (~93%) are forecast to come close to target.

2

Biology is forecast to fall from 153% to ~70%. Secondary overall: ~86%.

NFER analysis of DfE ITT Census and Apply data to February 2026 (Worth & Scott, 2026).

International recruitment and the challenge of staying

England widened access to training bursaries for international physics and languages candidates. In physics, 63% of trainees were non-UK nationals in 2025/26, up from 12% in 2021.

Visa costs

“super expensive to get a visa”

International trainee on the cost of staying after training (p. 53)

School sponsorship and upfront immigration costs can obstruct entry into teaching jobs.

Housing support

“leaving them to find somewhere to live?”

International teacher on gaps in recruitment agency support (p. 37)

Securing a post can still leave teachers without practical help to relocate.

Workload

“I never worked [such] long hours back [home]”

International teacher comparing working hours (p. 66)

Tailored induction, mentoring and manageable working conditions matter for retention.

Interview excerpts: DfE / IFF Research (2025), pp. 37, 53, 66 (2024 fieldwork). Physics figures: NFER (2026).

About two in three teachers from the 2020 cohort remained after five years

89.7%

of teachers who qualified in 2024 were in England's state-funded schools one year later

67.4%

of the 2020 cohort were there five years after qualifying

Some leavers move to independent schools, other UK nations or other education roles, and some return later.

Experience carries knowledge of subjects, pupils and school routines. Departures also add mentoring and extra classes for colleagues.

DfE (2026a), School workforce in England: reporting year 2025 (June 2026); Long & Bridges (2026), section 2.4.

Reported hours have fallen slightly, and more teachers find workload acceptable

Hours in the most recent full term-time week

Full-time leaders, 202556.5
Full-time teachers, 202451.2
Full-time teachers, 202550.1

Working Lives survey, Wave 4, January–May 2025; 10,808 teachers and leaders

"My workload is acceptable": teachers and leaders

17% 22% 26% 202220242025

About three in four teachers and leaders did not agree that their workload was acceptable in 2025.

IFF Research & UCL IOE (2025), Working lives of teachers and leaders: Wave 4, pp. 6–8.

Leavers most often cite workload and stress

DfE Working Lives Figure 11.1: proportion of leavers citing reasons for leaving, 2023 to 2025 1 2

Reasons rated important by teachers and leaders who left England's state schools, surveys of 2023, 2024 and 2025 (n = 461 in 2025).

1

In 2025, 74% of leavers cited high workload and 73% stress or poor wellbeing.

2

Fewer leavers now cite inspection pressure (69% to 53% since 2023), government initiatives (55% to 35%) and pay (39% to 25%).

IFF Research & UCL IOE (2025), Figure 11.1, p. 36; pp. 35–36. Crown copyright, Open Government Licence v3.0.

Starting salaries have returned to their 2010/11 real level; experienced teachers' pay has not

NFER chart: real earnings growth since 2010/11 for starting salaries, experienced teachers and average UK earnings 1 2

Real earnings growth since 2010/11, adjusted for prices. The dotted line is an OBR projection from March 2026.

1

Starting salaries in 2025/26 are back to their 2010/11 real level (+0.4%).

2

Experienced teachers' real pay is 8.6% below 2010/11, after a low of −13.5% in 2022/23. Average UK earnings rose 6.0% over the same period.

Worth & Scott (2026), p. 18. Sources: School Teachers' Pay and Conditions Document; Office for Budget Responsibility.

Policy responses

The government's pledge of 6,500 additional teachers: where it came from, what has been done, and how it is going.

Julian Herzog, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Where the pledge of 6,500 additional teachers came from

June 2024

Labour's election manifesto promises to "recruit 6,500 new expert teachers", paid for by ending private schools' tax breaks, including VAT on fees.

July 2024

Labour wins the election. Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson launches the recruitment drive on 8 July.

April 2025

The National Audit Office warns of uncertainties as secondary and college student numbers grow, and asks for a delivery plan.

Feb 2026

The DfE publishes its delivery plan.

What the pledge measures

  • At least 6,500 more FTE teachers by the end of this Parliament than in 2023/24
  • Baseline: 284,626 FTE
  • Covers secondary schools, special schools and FE colleges
  • Primary schools are left out because primary pupil numbers are falling

Labour Party (2024); Long & Bridges (2026), p. 7; NAO (2025); DfE (2026b), pp. 4–7.

What the government has done: attract, retain, develop

The DfE reports around £700 million of measures since July 2024, grouped in three areas.

Attract

  • Bursaries, scholarships and salary grants worth up to £31,000 tax-free
  • Simpler teaching apprenticeships
  • Support for applicants and returners

Retain

  • School teacher pay up by nearly 10% since July 2024
  • Retention payments up to £6,000 after tax in shortage subjects
  • Flexible working, including planning time at home

Develop

  • Early career support
  • Professional learning
  • Routes into specialist and leadership roles

DfE (2026b), pp. 4–5, 8–18; report section 18.

How the pledge is going, and the criticism

Progress reported

4,654 of 6,500 additional FTE

DfE workforce data, June 2026

  • School teacher leaver rate at 9%, the lowest since 2010 outside the pandemic
  • Secondary vacancies at their lowest for five years
  • 17,274 teachers returned to state schools in the latest year

Criticism and debate

1

National Audit Office (2025): secondary schools and colleges face a challenge finding enough teachers for growing student numbers.

2

NFER (2026): shortages continue in science, maths and computing, and special schools and alternative provision need more deliberate workforce planning.

3

Scope: the count leaves out primary schools, where teacher numbers are falling with pupil numbers.

DfE (2026a; 2026b), pp. 4–9; NAO (2025); Worth & Scott (2026), pp. 4–9.

Summary of the evidence on England

Indicators that have improved

  • Postgraduate ITT recruitment: primary 128%, secondary 89% of target in 2025/26
  • Full-time teachers' reported hours: 51.2 to 50.1
  • Workload rated acceptable: 17% (2022) to 26% (2025)
  • Starting salaries back to their 2010/11 real level
  • 4,654 additional FTE towards the 6,500 pledge

Pressures that continue

  • Subjects below target, e.g. business studies 30%, physics 78%, computing 81%
  • 67.4% of the 2020 cohort in state-funded schools after five years
  • About three in four do not find workload acceptable
  • Experienced teachers' real pay 8.6% below 2010/11
  • 74% of leavers cite workload; 73% cite stress
The picture differs between subjects, schools and career stages.

Report sections 11–20; sources as on previous slides.

Key takeaways

  • Teacher supply

    Recruitment, retention and where teachers are needed shape the workforce.

  • Job satisfaction

    Teachers can value their work while finding its demands difficult to sustain.

  • Teacher education

    Practical experience, specialist knowledge and professional judgement belong together.

  • Sustainable improvement

    Fair pay, manageable workload and support throughout teachers’ careers all matter.

→ / Space / click: next · ← back · F full screen · O overview · S speaker notes · move the mouse for controls
Speaker notes